Tuesday, October 10, 2006

Remakes .......... Naaaaaaaaah

As media persons and dailies waited with their bated breath for Ram Gopal Verma to reveal Gabbar's new look for his version of Sholay, or for the 20th Oct release to see what Farhan Akhtar's done with Don or what J.P.Dutta ha s done with Umrao Jaan, I was once again left exasperated at the futility of the whole situation. Ever since Devdas was redone and redux'ed by Sanjay Leela Bansali to rake in the big bucks lot of the filmmakers have been looking at remakes as an easier option to rake in the big bucks. Film making has for long been an art form meant to be an extension of your creative juices flowing on a 70mm screen. And that is exactly why remakes don't exactly do the trick for me. Remakes are almost like music remixes, in which a certain nobody piggybacks on a geniuses' back onto the road to fame and glory even though they don't or might not have a single creative bone in their body. I mean sure enough you will get people curious and talking when you announce a remake of a past flick but that is not curiosity being generated because of your talent. The real reason is because people identify and connect with the past flick and you shouldn't be getting any free buzz just because of that or any credit for that. And sure enough people will watch your movie because they know your story, scenes, dialogues and scenes from your movie making it a big success, but is that why you picked up a camera in the first place? Whatever happened to that little voice in you which asked you to make movies just because you loved to make em so that you could translate your little ideas and make them unfold of the big screen to make people root for your characters, laugh and cry with them, and take back with them a little piece of movie magic firmly stamped across their minds with them?

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Interesting, I'm thoroughly enlightened...nahhh not really ;)

Btw new gabbar looks like a charsi and I think Don might be the only remake that will live up to all the hype.

Jinguchakka said...

Remake is better than having the original English movies pointed at your "rip-off".
One can be cool about copying while doing a remake and no skeletons to hide.

Madame Mahima said...

happy birthdaaaaaaay
:D

M (tread softly upon) said...

Had to go back on your archives to confirm that it was actually your birthday and not one of madame mahima's jokes :)
happy birthday Rohan! I'm glad i didn't miss it.

--Sunrise-- said...

hey... just a passer-by... interesting thoughts on remakes (actually i came to your blog through a search for 'remakes' on blogger blog search... lol)...

but what caught my attention was your Stickam (sp?) thing... i like the songs you have on there... good taste (though i only know half of them, and am getting to know the other half of them)... :D am currently rocking to 'Staying Alive'... you heard Night Fever? that is what the beat reminds me of...

totti said...

wth its your birthday now??? And, i thoroughly disagree with you on the remakes :p
it's the power of story and its appeal and most people can't just shrug it off. king kong? lord of the rings? Ramayan..they are some stories i can watch in many different ways...but you are bound to have favorites based on nostalgia. And, i believe it requires some talent and creativity to re-draw on a age old canvas but still leave your mark. See what i am saying? :)..will update on the tournament..obviously if we had won, you would have heard..right?

Rohan Kumar said...

@Ad I shall send you to 'West Punjab' ;), I have a lil faith in Farhan so Don shouldnt be too bad hopefully

@Jinguchakka Reamke are ok but where's the creative genius in a remake?

@Mahima Thank you

@M Yeah she is pretty 'jokey'and thank you

@Sunrise Thank you about the two songs reminding you it might be coz both are by the same band Bee Gees

@totti Wth you dont even feel the need to wish me now you Fall 20-20 tournament loser, if it was just about 'the power of the story' and 'talent and creativity to re-draw on a age old canvas' how come no one reamkes flop movies, its not as if all of them are trashy movies are they?

@Perspective DO u agree or not is the question though ;)